In the NFC championship game where the 49ers ran madden coins all over the Packers, it had been more of a simple fact that they needed a dominant offensive line and I also still had to pass seven times. The 49ers didn't place a punter in the quarterback spot to acquire a hand that is faster - they were just better and that they overpower another team. Which is something that does not occur in Madden since all the time you may see 70 total defensive lineman plow over a 92 overall offensive lineman since he receives the animation.
There ought to be some penalty to this. Shooting a snap under center isn't the simplest thing although I'm not saying don't permit this. Maybe the punter can't see the play or they fumble snaps often or the turn the wrong manner handing the ball off. If I could afford not turning the incorrect way for handoffs when I was playing soccer I am sure it could be managed by a professional athlete as well. And taking a snap is just taking one. The downside of placing a punter in at quarterback should be that they will be worse at throwing the ball.
I mean certain but this is wee soccer. Being able to call two plays in the huddle and killing one while understanding verbiage of a NFL team for a guy that probably hasn't played anything aside from punter or kicker at a higher level is probably pretty tough while attempting to manage your capacity to kick and punt at the maximum level. Therefore it would be understandable if a play call was chased by them or forgot how to go for a play. Taking a long snap is not easy but neither is and beneath center snap of an nfl centre they have no practice period. I get what you are saying, but throwing a ball is the least of a punters worry when they were thrust into a QB position so that they shouldn't have the ability to run an NFL crime.
You've got the right to do anything you desire. Does that make it realistic? Does that produce fantastic gameplay? If this were not a simulation game sure, punters at qb will be fair game. But name one period in NFL history where a group set their punter in at QB multiple occasions. This really is an issue, until you can do this. MUT is same, far from a simulation style with competitive madden. I agree with everything you are saying. But Competitve Madden is completely different from Offline/sim people.
Competitive madden men look for exploits to more coins on mmoexp in Madden nfl's mechanics. It has been this way since the beginning of play. Just like back in the PS2 days with such and the Nano's. But us people who want the sim encounter play Madden nfl. It is like going to perform NBA 2k and expecting to play sim style in Rec, or My group. It just isn't happening.But it should not be that way. Madden touts itself as a simulation football experience and this can be its game style that is promoted. Clearly every game is going to get exploits. But the point is that this is allegedly a simulation football game and at its greatest level it doesn't even remotely resemble what we see occurring on Sundays.